We use limited cookies
We use cookies where necessary to allow us to understand how people interact with our website and content, so that we can continue to improve our service.
View our privacy policyTwo trans women and a women’s support service are bringing a challenge to EHRC guidance which is harming women’s organisations and upending trans people’s lives
It’s trans awareness week, and Good Law Project are celebrating by supporting a legal challenge against the EHRC’s transphobic code of practice.
A women’s sexual violence support service is bringing the challenge alongside two trans women. They say that the code of practice gets the law wrong by telling women’s service providers they can no longer include trans women in their services without opening up to cis men.
Labour’s equalities minister, Bridget Phillipson, brought this statutory guidance into force in August. It says that while associations – like Girlguiding – can remain trans inclusive, women’s service providers can’t. According to the code, any service provided for both cis and trans women must also be provided to cis men – otherwise it is “very likely” to be discriminatory. If a service doesn’t operate on the basis of sex recorded at birth, it continues, it “must be open to all”. The reverse applies to men’s services.
This blanket instruction puts inclusive organisations in an impossible position. It applies to all gendered toilets – encouraging a nationwide trans bathroom ban which Trump could only dream of. But it also applies to women’s pottery classes and gardening clubs. The guidance lacks nuance, ignores context, and pays no attention to the ways women want to run their own spaces and services. It is already having a devastating impact on trans people’s everyday lives.
Support After Rape & Sexual Violence Leeds (SARSVL) is one of the many trans inclusive women’s organisations affected by the new code. Their service has always been trans inclusive, but following the code would leave them with a stark choice:
In a powerful witness statement, they explain how their services have always been trans inclusive. Their evidence speaks to how their service is designed to account for the needs of all women, without any need to exclude trans women. They say that the voices of people and organisations with experience of working with survivors are not being heard.
SARSVL say that trans women survivors are a small and vulnerable minority, who need women’s support services for the exact same reasons that cis women do. They face particular barriers in accessing support, and SARSVL don’t want to be required to exclude them. They also fear that attempting to police the gender of the women who access their services will put them through further trauma.
As intersectional feminists, they believe that trans and cis women’s needs and rights should not be set up in opposition to each other, as this undermines both fights. They have never faced serious issues in running their inclusive service, and say there are other local services to which they can refer women who do not want to share a service with trans women – even though they don’t think anyone has ever asked. But now, they fear the code will encourage legal challenges which will force them to change how their service has always run.
The challenge is also supported by a witness statement from another women’s group, Girls on the Go, which runs women-only events, including colouring nights, singalong cinema and book clubs to help women of all ages make new friends, feel less lonely, and try new activities. Trans women have always been welcome at their events, and this has never caused any issues within their community, with cis women praising the policy.
But in September 2026 – shortly after the code of practice came into force – the organisation says they received an email threatening legal action against their trans-inclusive services. This is the first complaint Girls on the Go ever received about trans inclusion, and it seems to have come from someone who had never attended their events. They fear the guidance will encourage further pressure to change how they have always operated.
Girls on the Go say they can see no justification for excluding trans women from their events, and that this would undermine the principles upon which their entire community is based. They think all women should be able to benefit from the community and activities the organisation provides. Girls on the Go say exclusion would have a devastating impact on their trans women members, but it would also be a loss for other members, who would lose out on the friendship and community their trans members provide. They are concerned that adopting such a policy would encourage gender policing, and harm all women.
In their evidence, the two trans claimants describe the harmful impact the code is already having on their day-to-day lives. One issue is access to toilets – something which had never previously been a concern, but which now places serious restrictions on their social lives. One of the claimants is blind, and now feels particularly vulnerable trying to access public spaces. She also worries that forcing trans people to use accessible facilities will reduce their availability for other disabled people who need them. Both claimants have Gender Recognition Certificates and are not widely out as trans. They are now afraid that they will be outed as a consequence of the code.
But it’s not just about toilets. The claimants are now also very scared of having to go to hospital. New NHS guidance, based on the code, suggests that trans people should usually be accommodated on wards based on their sex recorded at birth. One claimant describes how “terrified” this makes her, the other suggests she may be less likely to seek medical attention as a result.
One of the claimants told Good Law Project she’s “just an ordinary woman who wants to live my ordinary life in peace – just like everyone else”.
“This guidance tells me I am not allowed to live that life,” she said. “It tells people they have to exclude me, even when they don’t want to. So now, instead, I am forced to live my life in fear.
But this challenge isn’t just about me. It’s on behalf of every woman who has ever had her gender policed.”
We think the code of practice is unlawful. It is based on a flawed interpretation of the Equality Act 2010, and it ignores the lived experience of countless inclusive women’s organisations – the real experts in how to run their own services in a way which supports all women. We also think it is entirely at odds with trans people’s human rights.
But we won’t end the hostility and cruelty of the EHRC’s statutory guidance without a fight. The anti-trans pressure group Sex Matters think even this awful code doesn’t go far enough. They want it to be even more transphobic. We can’t let them succeed. Together we can fight back.
Explainer: How the code of practice gets the law wrong and the legal arguments against it